The search for a new helmet

***DISCLAIMER –  NOT HONDA 250 RALLY RELATED CONTENT***

I’ve been searching for a new helmet over a year now as my current Shoei Hornet DS is showing it’s age and is not without faults. It has mostly been great and fits me well, but a few things need improving.

  • It stinks! I’ve washed it, but it still smells a bit. Not the helmets fault, but mine.
  • The chin curtain is at the end of it’s road
  • Visor is scratched (obviously), but the because of the design (flaw) of the helmet, the visor scratches  right in the middle as the visor touches against the peak when fully up. This happened with the clear visor too.
  • It’s not the most comfortable helmet at high speeds
  • It’s just generally quite worn from a lot of use
  • No flip down sun visor.k
  • My glasses fit, but inserting them could be easier

Based on this I came up with a list of things I wanted form my new helmet

Flip down sun visor

This feature really is great. I’ve rediscovered it, as I used my even older AGV for a while. For people wearing prescription glasses (like me) it’s even more valuable as it allows you to use your glasses while not having to change them to another pair (prescription sunglasses) when the weather so requires. Even fiddling with just plain sunglasses is a pain in real life. Anyone who rides in varying conditions (like roads that run in and out of forests) knows it’s not really practical to keep putting your sunglasses on and off. The internal flip down sun visor comes on and off in seconds! The peak that many  ADV helmets have, doesn’t really do much when the sun is low. This requirement limits out Arai. Arai’s version (external)  of a sun visor seems like a stubborn backwards solution to deal with their decision not to ever allow for an internal sun visor on their products.

Also, I find that the most comfortable way of riding “off road” is the visor open and the sun shade down. This provides the best airflow and still some protection toyour eyes. I much prefer this to wearing goggles which would again cause problems with glasses.

Safety

Obviously, but with some leeway. I really don’t care about helmet safety test results. My attitude is, that any reputable helmet manufacturer is capable of making their products safe enough for me and most likely has done so.

Comfort

This is the second most difficult thing to find for me. My long shaped head doesn’t usually fit well in most helmets. The problem usually is too much pressure in the forehead and/or loose feeling on the sides of  my head. This is something I’m not wiling to compromise one bit.

Weight

I’d like to keep the weight under 1600 grams which in turn limits the selection again some more. It’s not a safety issue, but a comfort issue. Modular helmets usually drop out at this point.

Eyeglasses

Here is where most helmets drop off from my list. Some designs just will not allow me to insert my glasses. I try to use contacts as often as I can, but buying a helmet that would not allow me to use my glasses is just not feasible. Arai usually shines in this regard, but no internal sun visor kills the whole brand for me.

Styling

Adventure style helmet would be ok, but I really don’t care too much. Function over form. I have no need to pose anywhere in my gear. I stay to avoid matte black stuff or visibility reasons, but then again would not wear hi-viz either if possible. It’s nice if the helmet colors match the bike somehow, but I’ve been known to change bikes so often that my helmets usually last for 3 bikes.

Noise

I’ve yet to encounter a truly silent helmet and because of that I’m not actively looking for one either. I usually ride with earplugs so helmet noise is not really a deciding factor.

Other stuff

Some people feel strongly about pinlock visors, D-ring buckles and stuff like that. I really don’t, as long as everything works as advertised.

My sources

This is the hardest part. I live in a country where the availability of different models and brands is less than ideal. This means I can not try all the models that might fit the bill. AGV AX-8 Evo or Nexx XD1 for example could not be found anywhere for testing.

What felt good on my head and could take glasses
Shoei GT-Air
HJC RPHA 70
HJC RPHA 11 (no flip down sun visor)
Shoei Hornet X2 (no flip down sun visor)
Arai Tour X-4 (no flip down sun visor)

What I would have liked to also try
AGV AX-8 Evo
Scorpion ADX-1
Nexx XD1

I also tried on many many others, but I find it useless to list all the helmets I didn’t like.

Helmet tests on websites are mostly rather useless repetitive semi advertisements that often lack details, critical thinking or actual user experience. Forums are a goldmine of actual user experiences, but as we all know you will find contradictory opinions on just about anything and often gets you more confused than anything else. That said I trust forums much more than I do reviews.

So what did I buy then?

 

rpha-70
HJC RPHA 70

 

Amazon has them in several colours:  HJC RPHA 70 Full Face Motorcycle / Motorbike Helmet – Plain White S

I ordered the HJC RPHA 70. The Shoei GT-Air felt slightly better/comfier, but the HJC was 300 grams lighter (which in relation is a lot) and a bit cheaper. For some reason only the RPHA models from HJC seem to fit me and the other HJC models don’t allow room for my forehead. Shoei helmets tend to all fit me pretty well as well as Arai.

*BTW, note to people professionally writing helmet reviews: Mention the weight on your reviews! “it’s light weight” means nothing especially when it doesn’t hold water.

So whats it like?

I’ll tell you once I get it and use it for a while.

UPDATE July 28th

It arrived. Test ride due for tomorrow. Also hot tip for the budget minded: check out HJC RPHA ST. Found some after I had already orderen the 70. Felt good amd it can be bought relatively cheap online.



UPDATE – FIRST IMPRESSION OF THE HJC RPHA 70

I took the first ride with the new helmet. A few notes

  • sun visor works well, it almost hits my nose but not quite
  • airflow from the top vent is good
  • when the clear visor is up, it reduces the airflow to the top vent quite a bit
  • chin strap pressed quite firmly against the back of my jaw, hopefully this will go away after use
  • the visor seals pretty well
  • noise is better than in the Hornet, but not good enough to ride without earplugs for long times
  • wind noise changes quite a bit depending on your head position. Upright riding is clearly noisier
  • no pressure points anywhere (besides the chin straps)
  • feels light and easy to wear

One thought on “The search for a new helmet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s